Grant Scoring Rubric Self-Assessment (Free PDF)
A free fillable grant scoring rubric worksheet: score your draft against the funder's criteria with evidence and page references, then list what to fix.
- PDF format
- 4 pages
- 32 KB
- Fillable
- Free
- No sign-up
Educational resource. Following this guide does not guarantee an award. Always follow your funder’s official instructions.
Download and fill in this worksheet
- 1Download the PDF. It is free and there is no sign-up.
- 2Open it in a PDF reader. Use a PDF reader or your browser so you can type into the fields.
- 3Fill it in or print it. Type into the fields and tick the checkboxes, or print it and write by hand.
- 4Check it against your funder's instructions. Review it with your team. The funder's official instructions always come first.
What is in the PDF
The full content of the file, so you can read it before you download. Blank lines and empty cells are the parts you fill in.
The real rubric is the one your funder publishes. Reviewers are asked to score against those criteria. This worksheet helps you score your own draft the same way before you submit. Part 1 uses the funder's criteria. Part 2 is a generic stand-in for funders that publish none. It is a practice tool, not a prediction of the score you will receive.
Draft details
Proposal title:
Funder:
Where the funder's criteria are published (document and page):
Scored by:
Date:
Part 1. Score against the funder's criteria
Copy each criterion and its points exactly as published. For each one, write the evidence in your draft and the page where a reviewer will find it. If you cannot point to a page, the score is low, whatever you meant to say.
| Funder's criterion | Points available | Our score | Evidence in our draft | Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total |
Priority or bonus points we are claiming, and where the draft earns them:
Three questions for each criterion
- Does the draft use the funder's own words for this criterion in a heading or first sentence?
- Could a reviewer find the answer in under a minute?
- Is the claim backed by a fact, a number or a document, not an adjective?
Part 2. Generic rubric for when the funder publishes none
Use this only when the funder gives no criteria. It reflects what reviewers commonly look for. It is not any funder's rubric, and the equal weighting is an assumption.
Score each criterion from 1 to 4 using the level descriptions.
| Criterion | 1 Weak | 2 Developing | 3 Solid | 4 Strong |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Need | Need is asserted with no evidence | Some evidence, but general or not local | Local, sourced evidence of a specific need | Local, sourced evidence tied directly to the people served and to this funder's priorities |
| Project design | Activities are vague or do not match the need | Activities are listed but the link to results is unclear | Activities, timeline and staffing are clear and plausible | Each activity leads to a stated result, with owners, dates and a reason the approach should work |
| Outcomes and evaluation | No measurable outcomes | Outcomes stated but not measurable, or no method | Measurable outcomes with a method and schedule | Measurable outcomes, named tools, who collects data and when, and how results will be used |
| Capacity | Capacity is claimed with no support | General description of the organization | Relevant experience, named roles and confirmed partners | Track record with results, qualified staff in place, and partners with documented commitments |
| Budget | Budget is missing detail or does not match the narrative | Budget matches in part, with weak justification | Every line ties to an activity and has a calculation | Every line ties to an activity, is calculated, is reasonable for the work, and other funding is explained |
Generic rubric scores
| Criterion | Score (1 to 4) | Evidence in our draft | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Need | |||
| Project design | |||
| Outcomes and evaluation | |||
| Capacity | |||
| Budget | |||
| Total out of 20 |
Second reader
Ask someone who did not write the draft to score it without seeing your scores. Compare afterward. A gap of two or more levels on any criterion means the draft is not saying what you think it says.
Second reader:
Criteria where our scores differed, and why:
Fix list
Start with the criteria that carry the most points and have the lowest scores.
| Criterion | What is missing or weak | Change to make | Who | By when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
How to use it
A proposal is scored by people working through a list of criteria, usually with a point value beside each one. Scoring your own draft against that same list shows where a reviewer would have to hunt for an answer, or would not find one. This worksheet gives you a place to do that and to turn the result into a short list of fixes.
- Find the funder's criteria first. They are usually in the funding announcement under a heading such as review criteria, evaluation criteria or selection criteria. Copy them into Part 1 word for word, with the points.
- Score on evidence, not intent. For each criterion, write what the draft says and the page number. No page, no points.
- Use Part 2 only when the funder publishes nothing. It is a generic stand-in, and its five criteria and equal weights are assumptions.
- Get a second reader. Have them score the draft independently, then compare.
- Fill in the fix list in order of points at stake. A weak answer on a heavily weighted criterion costs more than a typo.
- Score again after revising. The second pass confirms the fixes landed.
A high self-score does not mean an award. It means the draft answers the criteria clearly. To pull the criteria out of a funding document, use the NOFO decoder worksheet. For a second opinion on a draft, the reviewer simulation prompt scores it against criteria you paste in. To understand how reviewers read, see narrative strategy and reviewer psychology and the guide to peer review and resubmission. For common avoidable problems, run the red flags checklist.
Frequently asked questions
What is a grant scoring rubric?
It is the set of criteria, usually with point values, that reviewers use to rate applications. Each funder sets its own, and many publish it in the funding announcement.
Where do I find the funder's scoring criteria?
Look in the funding announcement or guidelines for a section on review, evaluation or selection criteria. If you cannot find one, ask the program contact whether criteria are available.
What if the funder does not publish a rubric?
Use the funder's stated priorities and application questions as your criteria, and use the generic rubric in Part 2 as a stand-in. Treat the result as a rough guide.
Does a high self-score mean we will be funded?
No. It means your draft addresses the criteria clearly. Awards depend on the competition, available funds and the judgment of the reviewers.
- PDF format
- 4 pages
- 32 KB
- Fillable
- Free
- No sign-up
About this document
- Written by Angel Reyes, DrPH(c), MPH, MCHES, PMP, PMI-ACP. Last updated November 18, 2026.
- Disclaimer: this is an educational resource, not legal, tax or financial advice. Using it does not guarantee an award. Always follow your funder’s official instructions.
- Every example in it is fictional. Replace examples with your own facts.
- Free to use and share with attribution under the terms of use. There is no sign-up and no form to download it (see the privacy policy).
- Found an error or have a question? Contact Angel.