AI Grant Reviewer Simulation Prompt for Draft Proposals
This AI grant reviewer simulation prompt runs a mock review of your draft proposal. You paste in the funder's published review criteria with their point values and your draft. The AI acts as a skeptical reviewer, scores each criterion using only that rubric, quotes the passages that earned or lost points, lists the questions a reviewer would ask that your draft does not answer, and ranks the fixes by points at stake. Its scores are an estimate and do not predict real reviewers' scores.
The prompt
You are a skeptical grant reviewer conducting a mock review. Evaluate my draft only against the published review criteria and point values pasted below. Do not invent criteria, requirements, funder priorities, evidence or facts. Do not use anything you know about this funder beyond what I paste. Do not rewrite the proposal. Be critical. I do not want encouragement. A reviewer reading many applications will not give me the benefit of the doubt, and neither should you. If the draft only implies something, treat it as not stated. For each criterion: 1. Give a provisional score within the stated point range. 2. Quote the exact passages from my draft that support the score. 3. Identify what is missing, unclear, unsupported or off target, and how many points you think it costs. 4. State the question a reviewer would be left asking. Label each weakness as either "missing from the draft" or "my inference," so I can tell a real gap from your interpretation. If the criteria or the draft do not give you enough to assess a criterion, say so. Do not guess a score. Then provide: A. A review summary in the style of reviewer comments: main strengths, then main weaknesses B. A total score, only if the rubric allows one to be calculated. Show the arithmetic. C. A ranked revision list, ordered by points at stake: the criterion, the problem, the evidence or content needed, and whether fixing it requires new information from my team or only clearer writing D. Anything in my draft that contradicts something else in my draft State clearly that these scores are an analytical estimate and not a prediction of actual reviewer scores or of a funding decision. Review criteria and point values: [PASTE REVIEW CRITERIA AND POINTS] Proposal draft (say here if this is the full proposal or only some sections): [PASTE DRAFT]
Written for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and similar AI chat tools. Replace each bracketed placeholder with your own details before you send it. Results vary by tool and version, so always check the output.
What to fill in
- [PASTE REVIEW CRITERIA AND POINTS]
- The funder's published review criteria, copied exactly: each criterion, its definition or sub-points, its point value and any scoring instructions given to reviewers. If the funder publishes a scoring rubric or reviewer guide, include it.
- [PASTE DRAFT]
- Your current draft with its headings intact so quotations can be traced. Say whether it is the whole proposal or selected sections, so content that lives elsewhere is not counted as missing. Remove confidential, personal and proprietary material first.
Why this prompt works
By the time a proposal is drafted, the people who wrote it can no longer read it the way a stranger will. A mock review supplies that outside reading. Colleagues are usually the best source, and they are not always available three days before a deadline.
- The funder's rubric is the only standard. The AI scores against the criteria you paste. It is told not to bring in general ideas about what makes a good proposal, which may not be what this funder scores.
- An instruction to be critical. AI tools tend to be agreeable and will praise almost anything. The prompt asks directly for skepticism and tells the AI to treat anything merely implied as unstated.
- Quoted evidence. Each score has to be tied to passages in your draft, so you can see what it relied on and whether it read you correctly.
- Missing versus inferred. Labeling each weakness lets you separate a real omission from a judgment call you may disagree with.
- The unanswered question. "Add more detail" is useless feedback. The specific question a reviewer would ask tells you what to write.
- Fixes ranked by points. A weakness in a heavily weighted criterion matters more than one in a minor section. Ranking by points tells you where your remaining hours should go.
- New information or clearer writing. The last column separates problems you can fix by editing from problems that need a decision or evidence from your team.
Why it is appropriate to use
Run this when you have a complete draft and enough time left to act on the results. A mock review the night before the deadline only tells you what you cannot fix.
Using AI as a critical reader is a sound use at this stage. It generates no content for the proposal, it works from your text and the funder's published criteria, and it is good at the mechanical part of reviewing, which is checking whether each scored element has an explicit answer.
Understand what the score is. It is one AI's estimate against a rubric. Real reviewers bring subject knowledge, experience of other applications in the same competition and their own judgment, none of which the AI has. A high mock score does not mean you will be funded, and the number will vary if you run the prompt twice. Use the reasoning, not the total.
It does not replace human review. Someone with knowledge of the field should read the proposal, particularly for technical soundness. Check the funder's policy on AI use and your organization's rules before pasting a draft into any AI tool, and review how the tool you use handles the data you give it. For how review panels approach a proposal, see grant submission, peer review and resubmission strategy.
How to check and revise the output
- Check the criteria and point values in the output against the funder's document. If the AI altered or added one, discard that part.
- Open each quoted passage. Decide whether the evidence is truly sufficient, only implied or missing.
- Sort the weaknesses. Real gaps go to the people who can fill them. Inferences you disagree with may still show that a passage is unclear.
- Work the revision list from the top. Fix omissions in high-point criteria first, then alignment and clarity, and leave polish for last.
- Resolve internal contradictions the review found, in every place they appear.
- Rerun after revising and compare which gaps remain, not just the score.
- Get a person to read it, ideally someone outside the writing team.
Frequently asked questions
- Can AI score my grant proposal?
- It can assign provisional scores against criteria and point ranges you provide. These are estimates for your own revision work. They are not official, they can vary between runs and they do not predict what real reviewers will decide.
- What should I give an AI for a grant review simulation?
- The funder's published criteria with point values and any scoring instructions, plus a draft with confidential material removed. Do not ask it to fill gaps with assumptions about what the funder wants.
- Can an AI mock review replace a human reviewer?
- No. It is useful for checking whether each scored element is explicitly addressed. A person with knowledge of the field is still needed to judge whether the approach is sound, the claims are credible and the argument persuades.
- Should I paste my full grant proposal into an AI tool?
- Only if the funder's AI policy, your organization's rules and the tool's terms allow it. Remove confidential, personal and proprietary information and any unpublished findings first. If in doubt, review selected sections.