Grant Proposal Red Flags Checklist (Free PDF)
A free checklist of 15 grant proposal red flags reviewers notice, each with a quick fix. Run it on your draft before you submit. Fillable PDF, no sign-up.
- PDF format
- 2 pages
- 27 KB
- Fillable
- Free
- No sign-up
Educational resource. Following this guide does not guarantee an award. Always follow your funder’s official instructions.
Download and fill in this checklist
- 1Download the PDF. It is free and there is no sign-up.
- 2Open it in a PDF reader. Use a PDF reader or your browser so you can type into the fields.
- 3Fill it in or print it. Type into the fields and tick the checkboxes, or print it and write by hand.
- 4Check it against your funder's instructions. Review it with your team. The funder's official instructions always come first.
What is in the PDF
The full content of the file, so you can read it before you download. Blank lines and empty cells are the parts you fill in.
Reviewers read many applications against the same criteria. These are fifteen things that make them doubt a proposal. Tick each box only when your draft is clear of the problem. The list comes from common review practice and is not a statement of any one funder's rules.
Draft details
Proposal title:
Funder:
Deadline:
Reviewed by:
Fit and instructions
- 1. The project does not match the funder's stated priorities. Fix: quote the priority you are answering. If you cannot find one, reconsider applying.
- 2. A required section, question or attachment is missing. Fix: build a checklist from the instructions and tick off every item.
- 3. Page, word, font or formatting limits are ignored. Fix: check the final file, not the draft. Limits are rules.
Need
- 4. The need is described with no local evidence. Fix: add one or two local figures with source and year.
- 5. The need is about the organization's finances. Fix: describe the gap in the community, not your budget.
- 6. Statistics have no source. Fix: give a source and year for every figure, or remove it.
Project design
- 7. Activities do not connect to the outcomes promised. Fix: trace each outcome back to an activity that could produce it.
- 8. Objectives cannot be measured. Fix: state who will change, by how much, by when and measured how.
- 9. The timeline is missing or unrealistic. Fix: list each activity with an owner and dates inside the grant period.
Capacity and evaluation
- 10. Capacity is claimed with adjectives, not facts. Fix: replace "experienced" with what you did, when and with what result.
- 11. Partners are named with no confirmed role. Fix: describe what each has agreed to do, backed by a letter.
- 12. The evaluation plan lists activities, not measures. Fix: for each objective, name the measure, the tool, who collects it and when.
Budget and finish
- 13. The budget does not match the narrative. Fix: check every number, role and activity appears in both.
- 14. Budget lines have no explanation. Fix: show how each amount was calculated and what it supports.
- 15. Typos, unexplained jargon, mixed terms and leftover text from another application. Fix: one person reads the whole thing cold, start to finish.
Your fix list
Write down the red flags you found and who will fix each one.
| Red flag number | What needs to change | Who | By when |
|---|---|---|---|
How to use it
A reviewer usually has a stack of applications, a scoring sheet and limited time. Problems that make a proposal harder to score, or that raise doubt about whether the project can be delivered, cost points quickly. This checklist gathers fifteen of the most common ones so you can find them in your own draft first.
- Use it on a complete draft, at least a few days before the deadline. A check the night before only tells you what you cannot fix.
- Have someone other than the writer run it. Writers read what they meant to say. A fresh reader sees what is on the page.
- Tick a box only when the draft is clear. If you are unsure, leave it unticked and look again.
- Start with the first three. A proposal that does not fit the funder or misses a requirement may not be read at all.
- Fill in the fix list, assign each item, and run the checklist once more after the changes.
This list reflects common review practice. It does not replace the funder's own scoring criteria, which you should read alongside it. For more on what goes wrong in federal applications, see federal grant writing tips and common mistakes, and for how reviewers read, the guide to narrative strategy and reviewer psychology. To have a draft scored against a funder's published criteria, use the reviewer simulation prompt, and to audit it against the instructions, the compliance checklist prompt. If you are still drafting, the grant proposal template sets out the sections.
Frequently asked questions
Why do grant proposals get rejected?
Common reasons include a poor fit with the funder's priorities, missing required elements, a need that is not documented, objectives that cannot be measured and a budget that does not match the narrative. Strong proposals are also declined simply because funds are limited.
What do grant reviewers look for?
They score against the funder's published criteria. In general they look for a documented need, a project that plausibly addresses it, an organization able to deliver, measurable results and a budget that matches the work.
When should I run this checklist?
On a complete draft, a few days before the deadline, so there is time to fix what you find. Run it again after revisions.
Does clearing all fifteen red flags mean we will be funded?
No. It means the proposal avoids common, avoidable problems. Funding depends on fit, the strength of the project and the competition.
- PDF format
- 2 pages
- 27 KB
- Fillable
- Free
- No sign-up
About this document
- Written by Angel Reyes, DrPH(c), MPH, MCHES, PMP, PMI-ACP. Last updated November 18, 2026.
- Disclaimer: this is an educational resource, not legal, tax or financial advice. Using it does not guarantee an award. Always follow your funder’s official instructions.
- Every example in it is fictional. Replace examples with your own facts.
- Free to use and share with attribution under the terms of use. There is no sign-up and no form to download it (see the privacy policy).
- Found an error or have a question? Contact Angel.